Image by Darren Evans
Daniel Hay Gordon, co-director of Thick and Tight, reflects on the role of satire in Dance
As a company, we regularly use parody and satire in our work, either by focusing on a specific person or style (parody), or by examining broader themes in society and politics (satire). For example, our latest seasonal show, Camp as Christmas, features not only a Virgin Mary and a Santa, but also Donald Trump, Melania Trump (and her body double), as well as Nigel Farage and two of his cronies as the Three Unwise Men. It is a show built for the current moment; if we were to stage it again next year, it would need updating. I believe satire and humour are generally at their best when reacting to the world around us. Our show may not be so relevant next year but some great works of art from the past manage to simultaneously speak of their times and ours. Take a play by Oscar Wilde; a brilliant production allows audiences to see how satire resonates across different eras and how, for example, depictions of hypocrisy can feel relevant and relatable many years later. When we think of dance, what historical works do this and who is making this kind of work now?
During lockdown, we created a short YouTube series called Not Fox News, responding to the headlines of the day. The main difference from a standard newscast (apart from the budget and scale!) was that movement served as the central language, rather than words. The videos portrayed the likes of then-Health Secretary Matt Hancock, Rupert Murdoch, and the friend of Jeffrey Epstein formally known as Prince Andrew. It was a very silly, quite strange and fab project and though it was modest, it sparked an ongoing question for us about dance’s role as a social commentator, an agitator, and a form of protest that speaks directly to the times we live in.
While dance can be funny, it is rare to see it using parody or satire to critique contemporary culture. Humour in dance is usually self-referential, poking fun at traditional dance techniques or classic productions. At some of its most outdated, classical ballet relies on physical traits like a dancer’s height or weight for laughs. Even in contemporary dance, we rarely see choreographers parodying politicians, the elite, or celebrities and when humour does appear, it often feels more cerebral than typically entertaining.
Entertainment is what we love to do; at the heart of our approach is a desire to connect with audiences through shared humour and current events. From the start, we aimed to make our work as entertaining and accessible as possible, using familiar public figures to invite people into an art form often viewed as elitist or hard to decipher without prior knowledge. We didn’t consciously plan it, but creating works about famous and infamous people has become our trademark. We call them “performed portraits,” blending dance with mime, lip-syncing, drag, and satire, pairing choreographed movement with the subjects’ actual voices and projected captions. Many people have never seen a live dance performance before, but most people are likely to know, even vaguely, who the Kardashians are. We feel it can give people a way in to enjoying an avant-garde ballet, if it parodies the Kardashians at the same time. (We made this ballet with 40 students: the setting was a post-apocalyptic world where only the Kardashians had survived. They’d learned to clone themselves, with their only nourishment coming from the consumption of dollar bills).
With so many incredible and horrendous people to satirise, why does dance so often return to the same stories and characters? Is it because this is what audiences demand? Is dance simply in a less politically active phase? Or are we no longer an art form that people look to for a reflection on society? A ballet like Kurt Jooss’ The Green Table is a political satire about Europe and war. Created in 1932, it is still regularly staged by top companies and studied by dance students. There were many choreographers making satirical and political works in the 1920s and 1930s, and The Green Table still has the power to comment on its own era and our world simultaneously. But isn’t there more we could be saying right now? What can dance say and do that no other art form can? How can it be a voice for what people feel and think now?
When I look outside of my own sector (primarily ballet and contemporary dance) it is clear how powerful movement can be. Take a platform like TikTok, where people create, replicate, and share dances on an astonishing scale. It may be an obvious observation, but dance is a universal language and an incredible way not only to communicate, but to celebrate and bring people together. Social media has shown just how strong dance’s ubiquitous appeal is. Dance companies may use social media formats to promote their work, yet are they truly tapping into the zeitgeist? Are we missing a trick by not using dance more to reflect the world around us?
Making this kind of work isn’t easy though, nor am I suggesting that Thick & Tight make this work successfully. If we do succeed, much of it comes down to two factors. Firstly, to being small-scale. That agility keeps us light on our feet, allowing us to make the work we want within relatively short timescales, unlike larger institutions that must plan years in advance and struggle to react immediately to the times. Even so, creating topical satire carries real risk; it is far from a guaranteed path to strong ticket sales or critical praise. We also go under the radar quite a lot, allowing us to comment from the outside. Secondly, we are a queer-led company, and as such we feel a responsibility to create work for and with marginalised people and communities. Centring those lived experiences, both in our company structure, in rehearsals and on stage, keeps us constantly tuned in to the world around us. We want Thick & Tight to be a place of solace and strength for people who are discriminated against and othered. What we do isn’t simply an aesthetic, something replicable, something trivial, something to garnish us with fame and fortune; it’s fundamentally queer, and in being so is a form of political protest.
When I think of all the terrible people in power, those who are harming both people and our planet, I feel like the only tools I have to challenge them are my artistry and my humour. I don’t particularly care how our work is regarded in the future; what matters most is creating work about what is happening right now, speaking directly to and connecting with people through the universal languages of movement and humour. Saying that, if people in the distant future, who happen to find our work under the rubble of capitalism, or in colossal vaults for the forgotten ‘content’ of the 21st century, manage to watch our work and in doing so, understand that we also found ways to parody and satirise the elites through choreographed movement and camp laughs…well I suppose it would quite nice, wouldn’t it.